"Growing Goodness": An Alaska Native Collection at Oberlin College

Collectors (1869-1887)

Collection Practices of the Time:

The objects in Oberlin’s Arctic Collection were first collected from indigenous communities in Alaska on various expeditions between 1869 to 1887. Collectors were often trained naturalists, focusing on animal and plant species of Alaska, and hired by museum curators with the secondary goal of preserving indigenous practices. These native communities were often viewed as ‘pure’ but dying out, and these curators intended to preserve the legacy and novelty of these cultures through material objects. This attitude was known as ‘salvage anthropology’.

On the whole, the expeditions these men led treated indigenous culture (and indigenous objects) the same way as they treated natural specimens - as if they were representations of a singular bounded (and endangered) ‘species’, not a living legacy of dynamic societies. Some collectors directly contradicted indigenous practices in favor of adding to their own collections, even to the point of robbing indigenous graves to collect bones and funerary objects. These practices influenced the types of objects that were collected, the lens through which they were viewed, and the subsequent treatment of those objects. On a base level, the objects were considered representations of natural history, not cultural history, and were collected in a historical moment that rarely upheld indigenous agency. 



Edward Nelson:




Edward Nelson, an ornithologist by trade, collected over 10,000 artifacts as he led expeditions from St. Michael, along the Yukon to Point Barrow, and then to Siberia. As he traveled and traded, he recorded cultural information in his field notes concerning the languages spoken, social life, economic practices, and photographs. His work has become a classic example of early anthropology. Nelson’s acquisitions make up more than half of the Oberlin Arctic Collection.









William Dall:

William Dall was a naturalist interested in mollusks and other invertebrates, who led an 1866 expedition down the length of the Yukon river (from St. Michael to Fort Yukon) to catalog animal species. He interacted with many native groups, collecting items made for everyday use as well as items made especially for trading with foreigners. The Oberlin Arctic Collection houses four objects collected by Dall.






Lucien Turner:
Lucien Turner accompanied the first International Polar Year project, a research exhibition known for its contribution to the mapping of polar regions and the collection of geophysical, meteorological, and oceanographic data. As a naturalist hired by the Smithsonian and stationed in Ungava Bay, Turner was able to build personal relationships that enabled him to acquire objects that were rarely traded. Turner collected four of the objects in Oberlin’s Arctic Collection, which include items typically used by Shamans and in ritual practice.





Other collectors included: Lieutenant P.H. Ray, Dr. L.B. Sherry, C.L. McKay, and J. Applegate

References

Margaris, Amy V. and Linda T. Grimm. 2011. Collecting for a College Museum: Exchange Practices and the Life History of a 19th Century Arctic Collection. Museum Anthropology Vol. 34(2):109–12.

Dall, W. H., Dawson, G. M., Ogilvie, W., & Trimmer, F. M. 1898. The Yukon territory: The narrative of W.H. Dall, leader of the expedition to Alaska in 1866-1868 : the narrative of an exploration made in 1887 in the Yukon district by George M. Dawson : extracts from the report of an exploration made in 1896-1897 by Wm. Ogilvie. London: Downey.

William Healey Dall. 2019.Wikipedia. Wikimedia Foundation. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Healey_Dall, accessed December 7, 2019

Edward William Nelson. 2019. Wikipedia. Wikimedia Foundation. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edward_William_Nelson, accessed December 7, 2019
 

This page has paths:

This page references: